Erotic asphyxia and the limits of the brain

A guy who enjoyed whacking off while trying to strangle himself has provided important evidence that an outward sign considered to indicate severe irreversible brain damage can be present without any lasting effects.

It was long thought that a body response called decerebrate rigidity – where the body becomes stiff with the toes pointing and the wrists bending forward – was a sign of irreversible damage to the midbrain.

This sign is widely used in medical assessments to infer severe brain damage and has been observed in videos of people being executed by hanging.

A new study in The American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology provides striking evidence that it is possible to recover from decerebrate rigidity owing to self-taped videos of a man who would strangle himself with a pair of pyjama pants suspended from the shower while masturbating.

The practice is known as autoerotic asphyxia and is based on the idea that restricted oxygen can enhance sexual pleasure – although is not recommended, not least because the medical literature is awash with cases of people who have died while attempting it.

Indeed, the gentleman described in the study did eventually die while hanging himself and when the forensic team investigated his house they found videos where he had filmed himself undertaking the risky sexual practice.

The three videos show him hanging himself while masturbating to the point where he lost consciousness and had the equivalent of an epileptic tonic-clonic seizure as he crashed to the ground. Each time, he regains consciousness and has no noticeable lasting effects.

In one of the videos, 20 seconds of decerebrate rigidity are clearly present. This was previously thought to be a sign of severe permanent brain damage – and yet he comes round, picks himself up and seems unaffected.

The study makes the interesting point that we still know very little about the effects of oxygen starvation on the brain.

For example, the widely quoted figure about brain cells dying after three to five minutes without oxygen is based entirely on animal studies and we don’t actually know the limit for humans.

As the authors note “There is no study to document this threshold of 3 to 5 minutes of ischemia [oxygen deprivation] to cause irreversible brain damage in human beings. Nevertheless, data obtained from animal studies were applied to human beings and the source of the threshold was later forgotten and assumed to be reliable.”
 

Link to PubMed entry for study.

3 Comments

  1. Posted October 24, 2010 at 1:02 am | Permalink

    Fascinating as usual.

    This topic hits close to home, as my young father suffered a heart attack and the paramedics didn’t arrive for 20 minutes, but then revived him. I wish they hadn’t. He survived for another week in a state that — well, if he had been a dog, someone would have shot him to be kind. Meanwhile, the ER doc refused to give my dad morphine because “he doesn’t have enough brain tissue to feel pain.” There are no words.

  2. Posted October 24, 2010 at 2:56 pm | Permalink

    Erotic autoasphyxiation, phantom penises…this site has officially obtained Most Awesome Blog status in my book and I’m adding it to my blogroll, STAT!

    Fascinating article, particularly for a hospitalist such as myself who unfortunately sees a lot of decerebrate rigidity in advanced cases of what we presume are brain death. These cases, however, are usually in the ICU and the patients have persistence of the decerebrate posturing, along with other indications of severe brain injury (EEG findings, etc). Still, this gives one food for thought…

  3. Amy
    Posted October 25, 2010 at 2:52 am | Permalink

    Women know that when your toes curl from orgasm, whether by yourself or with a partner… that’s a good one.
    I don’t understand the whole wrapping stuff around your neck thing. Why don’t people just hold their breath?
    A potential lover once asked me, do you know the most important thing to remember when you’re choking your lover during sex? I said, no, what? He said, to let go….


3 Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. [...] Μερικές φορές η ανθρώπινη ανοησία γίνεται η άκρη που ξετυλίγει το κουβάρι της γνώσης. Σε αυτή την κατηγορία ανήκει και η αυτοκτονία ενός άνδρα ο οποίος κρεμάστηκε ενώ αυνανιζόταν (erotic asphyxia). Μετά από έλεγχο στο σπίτι του βρέθηκαν βίντεο που είχε τραβήξει ο ίδιος τα οποία έδειχναν τις προηγούμενες φορές που είχε επιχειρήσει ξανά αυτό το επικίνδυνο ερωτικό παιχνίδι. Σε ορισμένα από αυτά τα βίντεο φαινόταν πως ο άνδρας αυτός είχε συμπτώματα βλάβης στον μεσεγκέφαλο (σπασμούς, “κοκκάλωμα” των καρπών κ.α.) τα οποία όμως δεν του προκαλούσαν μόνιμη βλάβη, κάτι που έρχεται σε αντίθεση στις μέχρι τώρα γνώσεις μας για τις βλάβες του μεσεγκεφάλου… [Mind Hacks] [...]

  2. [...] Erotska asfiksija- namerno ograničavanje dotoka kiseonika u mozak u svrhu postizanja, odnosno pojačavanja seksualnog zadovoljstva. [...]

  3. [...] Mind Hacks posted on erotic asphyxia. Here’s a review of the literature on autoerotic deaths between 1954 and 2004. Here’s a pdf of the first paper that I could find on this topic (in the British Medical Journal, 1960). After a gruesome description of the circumstances in which four men had died, the authors venture a Freudian hypothesis — somehow, the men wrapped themselves in plastic in order to simulate a return to the womb. (!) Then the authors make a more sensible claim: “A much less elegant and more superficial explanation is that these people were trying to achieve some uindifferentiated thrill or excitement from partial suffocation or anoxia. This factor may have existed but it does not explain the transvestism, sexual arousal, or complete enclosure of the body. It is an interesting reflection that the sexual impulse in man is so protean in its manifestations that a technical advance resulting in a new packaging material can result in a new perverse manifestation.” [...]

Post a Comment

Required fields are marked *
*
*

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 23,121 other followers