Depression, antidepressants and the ‘low serotonin’ myth

Bad Science has a fantastic article on antidepressants and the widely-promoted but scientifically unsupported ‘low serotonin theory’ of depression.

Owing to a huge advertising push by drug companies, not only the ‘man on the street’, but also a surprisingly large numbers of mental health professionals (clinical psychologists, I’m look at you) believe that depression is linked to ‘low serotonin’ in the brain.

The only drawback to this neat sounding theory is that it is almost completely unsupported by empirical evidence or scientific studies.

Experiments that have deliberately lowered serotonin levels in the brain have found that it is possible to induce ‘negative mood states’ (usually milder and as short-lasting as a slight hangover), but these do not even begin to compare to the depths of clinical depression.

In terms of patients with the clinical mood disorder itself, not a single study has found a link to reduced serotonin.

Bad Science neatly reviews the science, and also discusses a new research study which chased up journalists that propagated the myth to ask for their sources.

Needless to say, none of them had any sound scientific basis for their claims.

This is not to say that antidepressants don’t help treat depression, (evidence suggests they do – although the effect is more modest than drug companies would have us believe), or that neurobiology isn’t important (by definition, if it’s a change in thought and mood, it’s a change in brain function).

If you’re interested in the history of how the ‘low serotonin hypothesis’ came to be thought up and then subsequently promoted, despite the lack of evidence, Professional Psychology: Research and Practice recently published a great article on the topic [pdf].

Link to Bad Science on the serotonin myth.
pdf of article on the history and popularity of the myth.
Link to excellent PLoS Medicine article on evidence and adverts.

4 Comments

  1. comentator523
    Posted February 1, 2008 at 4:33 am | Permalink

    This is a clear example of how big an impact false information can make. It also clearly illustrates the true motives and concerns of drug companies, who would rather make a profit than make a truly effective drug that the public has a real understanding of.

  2. Posted August 7, 2010 at 8:04 am | Permalink

    Drug companies really twist the facts sometimes, although based on my own experience I can say that the effects of antidepressants are more than just “modest”. However, to cure the depression completely requires your own effort.

  3. jj
    Posted September 8, 2011 at 12:16 am | Permalink

    i wouldn’t say the information is “false” its not like a lil drug company came up with the with some lame excuse that low serotonin levels can cause depression. i thought this belief came back in the 40’s or 50’s? either way, no science is “proven” in my book, its just a method of observations and conclusions. before you know it someone else is changing it with different ways of observing. not only that but serotonin levels can be tested through ur blood….n if ur low….n claim to be depressed…n take antidepressants, n the problem gets solved. I think thats enough proof

  4. Mike
    Posted January 11, 2012 at 10:18 am | Permalink

    I think the finger pointing at mental health professionals is needed at the Psychiatrists, and not the Clinical Psychologists.

    It is amazing though that his still prevails within what is purported to be an evidence-based professional area.

    Scary really.


Post a Comment

Required fields are marked *
*
*

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 22,735 other followers