The importance of penis panics to cultural psychiatry

The Boston Globe has an excellent article about supposedly culture specific mental illnesses and how they are an ongoing puzzle for psychiatry’s diagnostic manual.

These conditions are called culture-bound syndromes in the DSM but they’ve always had a bit of ‘looking at the natives’ feel about them as many syndromes that are unknown in many non-Western cultures (anorexia, for example) aren’t listed as ‘culture bound’ in any way.

The Boston Globe article reminded me of a paper just published in the Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences by historian Ivan Crozier where he explores how koro – the fear that the genitals are fatally shrinking into the body – has been central to the definition of the ‘culture-bound syndrome’.

The history of how this fear, usually presenting as a penis shrinking anxiety and initially reported in South East Asia, became a prime example of a supposedly culture-specific mental illness, highlighting a bias at the centre of psychiatric definitions.

Penis shrinking fears have been reported from all over the world, but only certain cases tend to get defined as a ‘culture-specific syndrome’, because of our assumptions about what counts as the ‘real’ disorder.

Koro is a particularly good syndrome with which to play up the tension between psychiatric universalism on the one hand, and ethnic bias on the other. This disruption is clear when one surveys the varieties of koro. Some people (SE Asians) have koro because they belong to the “right” culture. Others do not, because they are suffering from another primary disorder (occidental sufferers), or because there is little in the way of psychiatric provision in their country (e.g., in Africa), and because there are other working explanations for dealing with penis panics (such as witchcraft).

Likewise, sometimes the material artifacts of masculinity are of crucial importance for explaining koro as a part of a culture (the penis clamps and piercings in Asia), but not in others (the pills western men can take when they are concerned about the penis size). These differences in treatment are not trivial. They point to an ethnocentrism in psychiatric conceptions of illness that is embodied in the DSM IV in the very place that is meant to address culture: the CBSs [culture-bound syndromes section].

Sadly, the Crozier’s academic article is locked behind a paywall (demonstrating a strange culture bound syndrome endemic in Western academia) but The Boston Globe article in free to access.
 

Link to Boston Globe article (via @DebbieNathan2)
Link to locked article on koro and culture-bound syndromes.

3 Comments

  1. Posted January 8, 2012 at 5:11 pm | Permalink

    very interesting. reminds me of this clip from the office:

  2. Posted January 8, 2012 at 5:42 pm | Permalink

    I think psychology is a culture-bound syndrome suffered by a lot of professional westerners.

  3. Ivan Crozier
    Posted March 14, 2012 at 8:36 am | Permalink

    I’m sure I can find a copy of my article if people are interested :]


2 Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. [...] The approach to the penis-shrinking anxiety highlights the bias that informs psychiatric definitions. [...]

  2. [...] Παρόλο που η πλειονότητα των ψυχικών διαταραχών απατώνται σχεδόν σε ολόκληρο τον πλανήτη, ένα ποσοστό από αυτές εμφανίζονται μόνο εντός συγκεκριμένων κοινωνικών ομάδων. Για παράδειγμα η ανορεξία απαντάται μονάχα στις δυτικού τύπου κοινωνίες και είναι εξαιρετικά σπάνια στις αναπτυσσόμενες χώρες της Αφρικής και της Ασίας. Το blog MindHacks περιγράφει μια πολύ ενδιαφέρουσα διαταραχή που παρατηρείται στις νοτιοανατολικές ασιατικές χώρες, η οποία είναι γνωστή με το όνομα Koro. Τα άτομα με Koro φοβούνται ότι το πέος τους έχει μικρύνει απότομα. Στο ίδιο άρθρο ο αρθρογράφος περιγράφει πως γίνονται αντιληπτά και αντιμετωπίζονται παρόμοια συμπτώματα στη Δύση, παρόλο που δεν περιλαμβάνονται σε κάποια συγκεκριμένη “δυτική” ψυχιατρική διαταραχή. [Mindhacks] [...]

Post a Comment

Required fields are marked *
*
*

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 22,433 other followers