A window on the mind

BBC Radio 4 science programme Frontiers just had a special edition on using brain scans to read the mind.

There’s been various reports in the media about research studies that have been able to identify subjective mental states or intentions from patterns on brain scans, mainly reported as a sort of ‘mind reading’ technology.

While these are genuinely interesting studies, they’re really not at the stage of being able to ‘read’ anyone’s thoughts.

The first thing to ask yourself when you hear this sort of claim is ‘has the effect been shown to work on individuals, or only as an average over a group?’. The next is ‘what task was the effect demonstrated on?’ and finally think about how reliably the effect could be demonstrated.

For example, on a recent brain imaging study that attempted to predict intentions, the prediction was made for individuals, but only between one of two possible options and the best reliability was 71%.

In other words, this study found that for each individual, when looking back at the data, with a choice deliberately designed to be predictable, their choice could be worked out before they made it about two-thirds of the time.

It’s hardly likely to concern anyone worried about the privacy of their thoughts.

It is a start though, and the implications of how the technology might be used as it becomes more accurate are certainly thought provoking.

The special edition of Frontiers talks to some of the researchers involved in this work and tackles the ethics of the technology.

Link to Frontiers on ‘Mind-reading’ (with audio).

One Comment

  1. Posted June 11, 2007 at 6:26 am | Permalink

    Hello Vaughan,
    Interesting post…I always wonder what is behind the mind walls? There may be a very complex issue that is in constant study. We have people of all kinds, including mentally ill, so-called normal minds, geniuses and so forth. The mind has been notorious to play tricks on us, let us down, skip to another level and so forth. It seems with the war between the brain and self there is never a winning ticket.
    But this post which is sharing information about reading mind is very interesting.


Post a Comment

Required fields are marked *
*
*

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 23,535 other followers